A Lutheran Priest, Self-Refuting Sola Scriptura, and Brave Sir Robin - Apologetics for the Masses #564
Unsubscribe/Subscribe
https://www.biblechristiansociety.com/newsletter/unsubscribe - to unsubscribe from this newsletter
https://www.biblechristiansociety.com/newsletter - to subscribe to this newsletter
Topic
A discussion of Sola Scriptura, and how it is self-refuting, with a Lutheran priest...until he runs away.
Introduction
When last we checked in on Lutheran pastor Rev. Timothy Selim, I was asking him questions which he could not, or simply would not, answer. If you were with us in the last episode of How the Lutheran Turns, you may recall that he said he often read the Catechism. Then, later in the conversation, he stated that the Catholic Church teaches that the Pope, and not Jesus Christ, is the Head of the Church. So I pointed out several places in the Catechism, which he claimed to often read, that directly state Jesus Christ is the Head of the Catholic Church and asked him if he would then admit that the Catholic Church teaches that Jesus Christ is indeed the Head of the Catholic Church, and not the Pope. He didn't answer. So, I asked him again. Again he didn't answer. What he did do, though, was abandon that thread and start a new thread entirely with a post on Sola Scriptura.
Well, I replied to his post on Sola Scriptura by giving 3 ways in which Sola Scriptura is self-refuting (which you'll see below), but I wasn't going to let him off the hook in regard to the question about who the Head of the Catholic Church is - Jesus, or the Pope?
So, below, I start off with his Sola Scriptura post. It started with a nice-looking graphic and then he added some further commentary. I've put a line in his post to separate the content of the graphic from his comments about the graphic. Everything above the line is what was contained in that graphic. Everything below that line was what he additionally stated about Sola Scriptura. Then I have my reply to his post, and from there, it's off to the races...
{NOTE: A few people took me to task for referring to Pastor Selim as a "priest". They said Lutherans don't call their ministers "priests," they call them "pastors". And also that Lutherans don't have valid holy orders, so they can't be priests. Well, they are absolutely right that Lutherans do not have valid holy orders and indeed are not actually ordained priests. However, I have often heard Lutherans, from way back, referring to their ministers as priests. Not all Lutherans do, but there's a decent number of them that do, particularly in Europe. So, I referred to Rev. Selim as a "priest", simply because a number of Lutherans refer to their ministers as such. Just like I call Anglican ministers "priests," even though they also do not have valid holy orders. I wasn't making any kind of theological statement by doing so.}
Challenge/Response/Strategy
Sola Scriptura Post - Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
{Graphic}
SOLA SCRIPTURA
Scripture Alone
Sola Scriptura means that Holy Scripture alone is the inspired, inerrant, and final authority for all matters of faith and life. Scripture is God's own Word breathed out by the Holy Spirit (2 Timothy 3:16-17), and it is the only infallible rule and norm by which all teachings, traditions, and human opinions must be measured. "All Scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for training in righteousness; so that the man of God may be adequate fully equipped for every good work. (2 Timothy 3:16-17)."
{End of graphic}
---------------------------------
"Sola Scriptura" is Latin for “Scripture alone.” It expresses the conviction that the Holy Scriptures are the only infallible rule and standard by which the Church’s teaching must be judged. God’s Word doesn't receive its authority from pastors, church councils, traditions, or even the Church itself. Scripture is authoritative because it is God’s Word, given through the prophets and apostles (2 Tim 3:16–17).
But it's important to note that Scripture alone doesn't mean Scripture *without* the Church. Christians have always learned the faith through preaching, teaching, creeds, and confessions. Lutherans treasure the ancient creeds and the Book of Concord precisely because they faithfully confess what Scripture teaches. These writings serve as witnesses to biblical truth, not as another source of revelation standing beside or above the Bible. When human teachings contradict God’s Word, Scripture must have the final say (Mark 7:8–13). It is the measuring stick by which we judge all doctrine and teaching within the Church.
Nor does Sola Scriptura mean that every individual interpretation is automatically correct. We read Scripture carefully, within its context, attending to its language, the whole counsel of God, and the Church’s faithful teachers. Like the Bereans, we are called to examine what we hear against the Scriptures (Acts 17:11). The question isn't just, “What does this passage mean to me?” but “What has God actually said?”
Most importantly, Scripture isn't an end in itself. Its testimony leads us to Jesus Christ, who died and rose for the forgiveness of sins. As Jesus said of the Scriptures, “It is these that testify about Me” (John 5:39). The principle of Sola Scriptura protects the Church from replacing Christ’s promises with human inventions and keeps our faith anchored in the Word through which God makes His Savior known.
My Reply
Sola Scriptura is self-refuting in 3 ways:
1) Nowhere in the Bible does it say, "Holy Scripture alone is the inspired, inerrant, and final authority for all matters of faith and life." I.e., Sola Scriptura is not in the Scriptura. Let's take, for example, the Gospel of Mark. Where does the Bible say that the Gospel of Mark is "the inspired, inerrant, Word of God"? Book, chapter, and verse? How about the Letter to the Hebrews? The Gospel of John? And so on. Furthermore, to cite 2 Tim 3:16-17 as "proving" Sola Scriptura is to ignore what that passage actually says, as well as the context. This passage says - no more, no less - that all of Scripture is the inspired Word of God. Amen! And, in context (going back to verse 15), this passage is talking about the Old Testament - the Scriptures Timothy had known from his childhood. So, if it proves anything "sola", it would be proving Sola [Old Testament] Scriptura. Any Sola Scriptura believer good with that? Plus, the passage nowhere says Scripture "alone". The word "alone," or "only," is not there no matter how much Protestants want it to be.
2) If Scripture is the only "infallible" rule and norm by which all teachings must be measured, then how does one even know what the Scriptures are? Is there a list, in the Bible, that tells us which books should be in the Bible? No, there isn't. Which means, in order to have the Bible in the first place...in order to know which books are or are not the inspired, inerrant, Word of God...we must rely on some authority outside of the Bible to tell us. So, how can it be Sola Scriptura when you have to rely on an authority outside of Scriptura in order to know what the Scriptura is? That is a logical contradiction.
Plus, if only the Bible is infallible, then whatever authority you relied upon for believing what is or is not Scripture, is, by definition, not infallible - i.e., it is prone to error. Which means, that the best you can say about the Bible is that you "think" the canon of the Bible is correct, but you can't be absolutely sure. Or, as R.C. Sproul (a Protestant theologian) put it: the Bible is a "fallible list of infallible books". Which is an insanely illogical thing to say. How can you know the books of the Bible are infallible, if you're not infallibly sure they are actually the Word of God? If you're not infallibly sure they actually belong in the Bible? Is there anyone who believes in Sola Scriptura who can actually answer these questions?
3) Sola Scriptura believers do not believe in Sola Scriptura, as they claim they do. What they actually believe in is Sola [My Personal Fallible Interpretation Of] Scriptura. They are all the time quoting Scriptures and then saying, "What that means is...," and then they proceed to give you their private, fallible interpretations of whatever passage they have quoted. The dogma of Sola Scriptura is actually useless for determining what is or is not authentic Christian teaching and practice, because whenever there is a dispute as to what this or that passage of Scripture means - and there are many, many, many such disputes just within the walls of Protestantism - the best the disputants can do is one person's personal, non-authoritative, fallible interpretation of Scripture vs. the other person's personal, non-authoritative, fallible interpretation of Scripture.
There is no authority within Protestantism that can definitively decide disputes as to what any given verse or passage of Scripture means. There is no authority within Protestantism that can definitively decide what is or is not authentic Christian doctrine and practice. So, the best Protestants can do in regard to any one of their teachings and practices is to say, "To the best of our knowledge, we believe this is true."
And, even if everyone agrees as to what any given verse or passage means, the best they can say about it is that, in their fallible opinion, the verse or passage means such and such. They cannot, however, say, definitively - i.e., infallibly - that they have absolute assurance that their opinion is correct. I always get a kick out of it when a Sola Scriptura believer tells me they have "absolute assurance" of their salvation, when their "absolute assurance" is based on their "fallible" interpretation of a book that they "think" has a very high chance of "probably" being the inspired, inerrant, Word of God.
Sola Scriptura is a dogma for the unthinking.
Comments/Strategy
There were a number of different points in his initial post that I could have gone after (and will discuss here), but the strategy I chose instead was to point out the contradictions in Sola Scriptura that lie at its very foundations. So I discussed 3 ways in which Sola Scriptura makes no logical, as well as scriptural, sense, whatsoever.
Now, a few points regarding his comments on Sola Scriptura:
1) "...the conviction that the Holy Scriptures are the only infallible rule and standard by which the Church’s teaching must be judged." The Scriptures are "infallible" in the same way a tree or a rock is "infallible". Can a tree make an error? No. Can a rock? No. They do not have the capacity to decide between one option or the other. Between truth and error. They have no decision-making ability. Neither do the Scriptures. Yes, the Scriptures are "inerrant," in that they do not contain error - any error - however, the Bible itself cannot, for example, decide for you whether the Lutheran understanding of Baptism - that it is spiritually regenerative - or the Evangelical understanding of Baptism - that it is purely symbolic - is correct. The Bible cannot make an error because it does not have the capacity to make a decision, one way or the other. Again, the Bible is "infallible" in the same way a tree or a rock is "infallible". So, to say the Bible is "infallible," is a bit of a misnomer.
2) When he says that "God’s Word doesn't receive its authority from pastors, church councils, traditions, or even the Church itself," what is he actually doing? What he's doing is accusing the Catholic Church, in a backhanded way, of believing it gives authority to God's Word. Which is a lie. The Church believes no such thing. The Church believes it is an authoritative witness as to what is or is not God's Word, but it in no way claims that the Scriptures have authority as "God's Word" simply because the Church says they do. I thought he said he reads the Catechism?
3) Sola Scriptura "doesn't mean Scripture *without* the Church." Well, actually, by his definition, it kinda does. Notice how everything he says after that essentially relegates the Church to an afterthought when it comes to settling doctrine and dogma and such. If the "Church" doesn't square with Scripture, according to whoever's interpretation of Scripture, then forget the Church.
4) I had to laugh when he said, "Nor does Sola Scriptura mean that every individual interpretation is automatically correct..." Well, no, no one says Sola Scriptura means "every" individual interpretation of Scripture is automatically correct. However, every individual who interprets Scripture believes their interpretation is indeed correct. Ask Rev. Timothy Selim if he thinks his interpretations of Scripture are correct? He'll tell you they are. So will every other Sola Scriptura believers you ask. Nowhere does Rev. Selim address the problem of fallible individuals fallibly interpreting "infallible" Scriptures to come up with apparently "infallible" doctrine and dogma. How, exactly, does that work? And when he said, "The question isn't just, 'What does this passage mean to me?' but 'What has God actually said?'" It is amazing how, pretty much 100% of the time every individual's answer to the question: "What does this passage mean to me?" is going to be the exact same as their answer to the question: "What has God actually said?" Does Rev. Selim somehow think anyone would ever come up with a different answer between those two questions? Really?! Can you imagine someone saying, "Hey, Romans 3:5-8 means this to me, but I think it means something different to God?" That is the kind of absurdity you will get when defending the indefensible - Sola Scriptura.
Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
I originally posted my response to the heterodox and apostate declaration of the apostate Bishop. It is a fallacy that the Roman Church is not in schism, though Episcopal in polity, the burial refuses to exert it's author into remove these ships from their positions. The Roman Church is in error from it's beginning and is promised on false belief and practice. The words of Christ to Peter were based on Peter's Confession of the Christ being the Son of the Living God, just after this, Christ called him Satan.
Peter was not the first Bishop of Rome, as that was not a possibility before half way through the second Century and before that, the Churches in Rome were house Churches that were led by a Presbyter. The Churches in the East had cosmopolitan Bishops before the Churches in the West.
I used to love listening to you and other Roman apologists on catholic radio, but none of them have a clue as to what Luther was trying to teach, he was Dr. of Theology in the Church.
I used to think that Evangelicals were harder to talk to, but with your hubris and sarcasm, it is apparent that you don't really want to have a discussion, but just want to defend and promote the heterdox beliefs of the Roman Church. Which by the way, seems to want to ignore the threat of Islam, an antichrist religion, and give them a place in the Vatican, the Office of the Pope is indeed anti-christ as is stated in the Lutheran Confessions.
God Bless!
My Reply
In other words, you can't respond to my arguments with cogent, rational, and logical arguments of your own, so instead you give me your opinions and your incredible ignorance of Church history. You say you want to have a "discussion," but you start your "discussion" by attacking my church. Then, when I respond with rational, logical, and biblically-based arguments, what do you do? Accuse me of hubris. Really? There's a concept in psychology known as "projection," ever heard of it?
And, if I didn't want to have a discussion, then why did I allow your post in my forum? I am not afraid of your Lutheran errors, but you seem to be deathly afraid of my Catholic truths.
Peter was the 1st bishop of Rome. We have the lists of all the bishops of Rome from the early centuries of the Church. As you were asked in a post on that other thread, where is the Lutheran list of Lutheran bishops that date back to the 1st century? You do know that is how heresies were combatted in the Early Church don't you? The heretics were asked to produce their lists of bishops that dated back to the Apostles. When they couldn't do so, it was a sure sign that what they were teaching was heresy. So, where is your list?
And, if you're going to call my Church schismatic and apostate, and call the Pope the Anti-Christ, while accusing me of hubris, then I'm going to call you a heretic. So, heretic, produce your list of bishops that date back to the founding of the Church.
Furthermore, regarding Peter, if Peter wasn't all that, as you are saying, then why did Jesus leave him in charge of His entire flock right before He ascended into Heaven (John 21:15-19)? Very curious, don't you think?
Okay, now that you have tried to distract from the fact that you can't answer my arguments about Sola Scriptura, why don't you go ahead and make some attempt to answer my arguments about Sola Scriptura.
Comments/Strategy
What's he doing here? He's trying to distract from the arguments I'm making and the questions I'm asking. So I called him on it. And you should do the same with the folks you dialogue with. And I didn't follow him down the various rabbit trails he was trying to run down. I closed this part of my response by getting back to Sola Scriptura and demanding he answer my arguments on it.
Furthermore, this guy is as arrogant as the day is long. "I used to love listening to you and other Roman apologists on catholic radio, but none of them have a clue as to what Luther was trying to teach, he was Dr. of Theology in the Church." First of all, I have to say, again, that it is a bit bizarre to say you "love" listening to apologists of a Church that you consider to be heterodox, schismatic, and apostate, and whose leader is supposedly the anti-Christ. Notice how, in the first half of the sentence, he is feigning a complement of me and "other Roman apologists," but then in the 2nd half of the sentence, he says that none of us have a clue as to what Luther was trying to teach! Well, then how is it you "loved" listening to us clueless, ignorant, apostate apologists? What a joke. And all of us clueless Roman apologists have no clue what Luther was trying to teach because Luther was a "Dr. of Theology in the Church". Really? Does he give an example of how we misunderstand Luther? Of course not. But, undoubtedly, the brilliant Rev. Timothy Selim perfectly understands Luther and is thus able to personally condemn the entire Catholic Church, and all 1.4 billion people in it, as being heterodox and apostate and schismatic. And he accuses me of hubris? Although, he does love listening to Catholic radio.
Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
In your initial refutation of Sola Scriptura, you stated that the Scriptures were all Old Testament. Of course they were! All of the Scriptures are a testimony to God's plan of redemption achieved through Jesus the Christ. The Old Testament is all about Jesus, the prophecies, the Law, the wisdom literature and the psalms. Jesus explained this to the two disciples on the road to Emmaeus. So it is logical to deduce that the Apostolic teaching was the Gospel of Jesus Christ, the Bereans were commended for checking what they were taught with Scripture to make sure that it was true.
Fr. Raymond E Brown, a Roman Scholar has also written that Peter was not the 1st Bishop in Rome as the Church in Rome was led by Presbyters in various locations until the mid first Century.
What I find interesting is that there is so much hate for Lutherans in your subscribers. If I were approached about a heterodox teacher within my Church body, I would probably encourage someone to find a faithful Roman Parish or teacher if there were no Confessional Lutheran options, that was the point of my original comment. It seems that the Roman Church would rather extend grace to non Christians than to those who profess the Name of the Incarnate Son of God, even though some the understanding may be heterodox.
My Reply
Why do you keep avoiding direct answers to my questions? One in particular that I am going to ask you again, for the 4th time:
Will you admit, based on your oft readings of the Catechism, and given my many citations from same, that the Catholic Church believes, and proclaims, that Jesus Christ is the head of the Church...yes or no?
Are you unable to answer the question, or simply unwilling?
Comments/Strategy
Ignore all the static someone tries to toss into the conversation. Fr. Raymond Brown? Who cares what Fr. Raymond Brown thinks? Is he the Magisterium of the Church? No. Furthermore, if you agree with Fr. Raymond Brown who supposedly said Peter was not the 1st Bishop of Rome, which would make Fr. Raymond Brown a heterodox priest, then why do you not agree with Fr. Raymond Brown when he says the Bible contains 73 books? Or that the Eucharist is indeed the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Jesus Christ? Or that the Catholic Church is indeed the Church founded by Jesus? And Rev. Selim says he would encourage a Confessional Lutheran to find a "faithful Roman [i.e., Catholic] Parish" if there were no Lutheran churches around? Really?! Doesn't he mean a faithful, heterodox, schismatic, apostate Roman Parish that answers to the anti-Christ? What is up with this guy? See what happens when you pretend to be all nice and ecumenical when you actually hate the folks you're pretending to play nice with? Just one contradiction after another.
And his statement about the hatred for Lutherans amongst my subscribers is laughable. Here he is, referring to the Catholic Church as apostate, schismatic, heterodox and so on, and referring to "Roman apologists" as clueless and that the Catholic Church puts the Pope - the anti-Christ - before Jesus Christ as Head of the Church and so on, yet he complains about "so much hate for Lutherans" among my subscribers? What hate? Quote from the hateful posts. He didn't do so because he can't. He was making it up as part of the excuse for what he was about to do...turn tail and run.
So I'm just laser-focused on this one question I'm trying to get him to answer and will not be deterred from it no matter how hard he tries to run away from it.
Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
Of course, Jesus is the Head of His Church.
My Reply
That's not what I asked. I asked if you will admit that the Catholic Church believes, and proclaims, that Jesus is the head of the Church...yes or no?
Comments/Strategy
Word games. Trying to be oh so clever. Nasty little hobbitses...
Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
Yes.
My Reply
Then why, in a previous post, did you state the following: "Christ is the Head of the Church, not the Bishop of Rome?" Who is it you were referring to as believing the Bishop of Rome is the Head of the Church?
Comments/Strategy
He has backed himself into a corner. I have shown, using his own words, that he is not being entirely honest and forthright in his dealings with me and, undoubtedly, with most Catholics he comes across - at least, with his postings on social media. First he makes a statement claiming, in essence, that the Catholic Church teaches that the Pope, and not Jesus, is the Head of the Catholic Church. But, when faced with having to admit that he knew his statement was not true, and that he was basically lying when he wrote it, watch how he squirms and then pulls a Brave Sir Robin...and runs away.
Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
Will you admit that Christ is Head of the Confessional Lutheran Church?
My Reply
Answer my question first: Why, in a previous post, did you state the following: "Christ is the Head of the Church, not the Bishop of Rome?" Who is it you were referring to as believing the Bishop of Rome is the Head of the Church?
Comments/Strategy
Again, trying to distract. Not going to let that happen.
By the way, no, I would never admit that Christ is the Head of the Confessional Lutheran church. For one thing, the Confessional Lutheran church is not really a church. Secondly, there is only one church that Christ is the Head of because there is only one church that Christ founded - the Catholic Church. The Confessional Lutheran church is an impostor.
Lutheran Pastor Timothy Selim
You absolutely know that the average Roman parishioner would answer that question in the affirmative. The well catechized might possibly add comments about the the Vicar of Christ and the Magestiruum being the voice of Christ in time, but the majority of Roman Catholics, like every other Christian Faith Tradition are not interested in a deeper dive into Doctrine and how to truthfully interpret Sacred Scripture. I have already pointed out that the Church in Rome did not have an actual Bishop until the mid 2nd Century, thus negating the ideaa of Apostolic Succession on which the Roman Church rests.
God Bless you, and may He lead you into the Truth of the Evangelical Catholic Faith.
I will leave your heterodox group.
My Reply
Of course you will leave, because I caught you, a Lutheran priest, being duplicitous and deceitful and malicious. And you know that is exactly what you would have shown of yourself if you had answered my last question.
One of your 1st remarks on the other thread was to say that "Christ is the Head of the Church, not the Bishop of Rome." With that you were implying that Catholics somehow do not believe that Jesus is the head of the Church, but the Pope is. Yet, you then stated you often read the Catechism. So, I pointed out to you several places where the Catechism - the official teaching of the Catholic Church - states, very clearly and very directly, that Jesus Christ is the Head of the Catholic Church, not the Pope.
When pressed on that, you had to admit that, yes, the Catholic Church does indeed teach Jesus is the Head of the Church. But, then, when I asked why you initially implied otherwise, what do you do? Instead of admitting that you were, essentially, lying about what Catholics believe, even though you knew better, and thereby admitting your extreme bias and, dare I say it, hatred, of the Catholic Church, what do you do? You pulled a Brave Sir Robin and...ran away. You are a coward and hypocrite.
And that garbage about how you find it interesting that there is "so much hate for Lutherans" amongst my subscribers. What a crock! As Fred Wolff [a member of my Facebook forum] asked you in another post - show me this hatred. Where is it? Have my subscribers intentionally misrepresented what Lutherans teach, as you have about what Catholics teach? Have they called Luther the anti-Christ as you have called the pope? Have they disparaged the Lutheran Church in the same ways you have disparaged the Catholic Church? No. So your claims are pathetic.
And, just so you know, you are going to be the subject of my next 2 or 3 newsletters. As I previously stated, it goes out to around 60,000 Catholics, and a decent number of non-Catholics, in all 50 states and some 80+ countries around the world.
But, I will do something for you that you would never do for me. I will give you the chance to reply to my newsletter. I would never receive the same opportunity in any forum of which you are the master. I know that because no Protestant has ever published my statements, in context, on their forums or in their newsletters. Error fears truth...truth does not fear error.
Comments/Strategy
Yeah, I was pretty harsh with this guy; although, I don't know if he ever saw that last post as he did, at some point, leave the forum. But, dealing with this guy - a religious leader who tries to come off as oh so ecumenical and open-minded and all, yet teaches doctrinal error and seems to have a deep hatred for the Church Jesus founded, and is, apparently, comfortable in lying about Catholics and their Church - kind of made me feel the disgust that I think Jesus must have felt with the scribes and Pharisees in Matthew 23, when He just tore them to shreds. I just felt a deep repugnance towards this man with all of his word games, his contradictions, his lies, his faux compliments, his contrivances, and his veneer of civility while all the time denigrating the Church in backhanded fashion over and over again.
But, if he wants to respond. I will post it. Error fears truth; truth does not fear error.
Closing Comments
I hope all of you have a great week. Please pray for the Bible Christian Society and for my family and me. And please know that I keep all of you in my prayers daily.
Donations
The Bible Christian Society is a non-profit organization that relies solely on your support to bring the truths of the Catholic Faith to tens of thousands of people throughout the U.S. and all around the world each year. If you would like to help us do what we do, you can donate online at:
https://www.biblechristiansociety.com/donations
or send a check to:
Bible Christian Society
PO Box 424
Pleasant Grove, AL 35127.
Anything you can do is greatly appreciated!
Unsubscribe/Subscribe
https://www.biblechristiansociety.com/newsletter/unsubscribe - to unsubscribe from this newsletter
https://www.biblechristiansociety.com/newsletter - to subscribe to this newsletter
